The tension between nostalgia and innovation in food practices
An explorative essay into Alain Passard's culinary approach.
In the dynamic realm of gastronomy, the interplay between nostalgia and innovation defines contemporary culinary practices worldwide. Nowhere is this delicate balance more pronounced than in France, where centuries-old dining traditions, deeply ingrained into the national identity (Ferguson, 2003), coexist with the imperative for culinary innovation as a response to pressing societal and economic challenges (Geyzen et al., 2012). Concurrently, the modern gastronomic scene is characterised by a frantic search for novelty (Urry, 1990), intensifying the tension between the comfort of the familiar and the relentless drive for avant-garde experimentation. This essay embarks on an exploration and critical examination of this tension through the scope of renowned French chef Alain Passard, who has influenced both France’s culinary evolution and the global gastronomic landscape. It will address his ascent to fame, the innovative culinary paradigms he introduced, and the criticisms and challenges encountered by Passard in his audacious quest to redefine French cuisine while honouring its storied traditions.
Alain Passard serves as a fascinating lens through which to examine the dynamic interplay of nostalgia and innovation in French cuisine. Born into a family with a strong artistic flair, Passard’s culinary journey started under the tutelage of his grandmother, a well-known cook celebrated for her skill in la rôtisserie (meat roasting) (Bouty & Gomez, 2011). From the age of 14, his training involved apprenticeship under the revered nouvelle cuisine chef Alain Senderens and work in prestigious establishments in Rennes, Brussels, and Paris (Passard, 2013); these laid the foundation for his rise to prominence. Distinguishing himself as a grill specialist, this prodigy achieved the remarkable feat of becoming the youngest chef to ever secure two Michelin stars by the age of 26 (Bouty & Gomez, 2011). In 1986, he opened his own restaurant, L’Arpège (arpeggio), a name paying homage to his family’s musical roots. Situated on Rue de Varenne, Paris, the venue became known for its exquisite dishes that highlighted the chef’s skill in grilling le tissu animal (animal flesh) and garnered its third Michelin star ten years later (Passard, 2013). However, rather than rest on his laurels, Passard astounded the culinary community in 2000 by announcing the removal of all red meat from the restaurant, instead placing vegetables at the heart of the menu (Bouty & Gomez, 2011). Given the conventional perception of steak and other red meats as quintessential elements of French cuisine (Magid, 2004), this audacious and unprecedented move was met with scepticism. Critics and the general media anticipated removal of its coveted Michelin stars and a significant loss of clientele (Johnson et al., 2005). Contrary to expectations, Passard’s decision not only retained the restaurant’s accolades but ultimately led him to become the father figure of vegetable-centric cuisine (Bouty & Gomez, 2011) and have a lasting impact on the direction of global culinary trends.
Passard is a prime example of innovation in contemporary French cooking. Alongside his decision to place vegetables at the forefront of his menu, he also made a bold departure from the conveniences of globalisation and year-round produce availability by forgoing his existing supply network. He purchased farmland in 2002 and began cultivating dedicated vegetable gardens to supply the restaurant (Bouty & Gomez, 2011). Spread across three distinct regions in France – the Sarthe, Eur and Manche – Passard’s farmland provides him with unique access to diverse terroirs that allows for in-depth experimentation (Passard, 2013). This farm-to-table concept not only affords him greater control over the quality and variety of vegetables used in his dishes but also underscores the significance of prioritising seasonal and locally sourced ingredients. The restaurant menu hinges entirely on the fresh produce delivered each morning and changes daily. Passard (2013) stresses that he never writes any of his recipes down, and that this approach is liberating, allowing him to craft culinary creations based solely on the recent offerings of his gardens. He prides himself on the ephemeral nature of his works (Dupuy, 2012). While haute cuisine often distinguishes itself through the use of fine products (Kallmuenzer et al., 2022), his dedicated team of ten gardeners makes L’Arpège one of the only restaurants in the world to self-manage its ingredient production (Passard, 2013) – a testament to its commitment to sustainability and culinary stewardship.
Beyond revolutionising the role of vegetables, Passard showcases his culinary prowess by applying meat preparation techniques to unconventional areas of cooking. An exemplary creation is Passard's signature dessert, tomate confite farcie aux douzes saveurs (candied, 12-flavour stuffed tomato), where the tomato is cooked over an open flame, challenging the conventional use of roasting primarily reserved for meats (Bouty & Gomez, 2010). In addition, Astier (2015) highlights Passard's innovative spirit through his use of flames to infuse smoky nuances, typically associated with meat dishes, into sweet courses.
Another notable departure from tradition lies in the presentation of his menus. Since the contributions of Carême in the seventeenth century and Escoffier in the nineteenth, the majority of upscale dining establishments and fancier dinners adhered to a shared script for menu construction (Schehr & Weiss, 2001). This included a formal name for each dish, with historical connotations in the name of the garnish or place of origin, presented in sequential order. Echoing this, Passard presents guests with a meticulously curated menu that lists each dish in sequential order but departs from convention by intentionally omitting any reference to culinary techniques and shifting the focus exclusively onto the primary ingredients. An illustration of this approach is found in the dish Haricot et pêche blanche à la menthe (Bean and white peach with mint), where the spotlight rests squarely on the essential components, devoid of any mention of cooking methods or sauces. This deliberate choice reinforces the chef's commitment to emphasising the intrinsic qualities of each ingredient and showcasing his creativity, without relying on extravagant or decorative titles (Dupuy, 2009).
Amidst this innovation, Passard has not completely abandoned his culinary heritage. Bounty & Gomez (2011) highlight that roasting, a timeless cooking technique, remains his preferred method, albeit now applied creatively beyond conventional meat-centric dishes. Other classic culinary techniques including braising and sautéing are skilfully integrated into his menus (Passard, 2015), a deliberate homage to the foundational methods that form the backbone of French culinary tradition. Furthermore, while his decision to cultivate private gardens to supply the restaurant was pioneering, the emphasis on seasonal and local produce aligns harmoniously with longstanding French tradition. The enduring value of terroir, which encompasses factors such as soil, climate, topography and local human tradition linked to a specific place (Wilson, 1998), is evident in this commitment. Finally, adeptly playing with nostalgia, Passard revisits classic recipes with his own creative twist. A prime example of this is his signature tarte bouquet de roses (rose bouquet tart), a reconsidered tarte aux pommes (apple tart), instantly recognisable to the French palate. As Holtzman (2006) underscores the inseparable link between food and memory, this blend of the familiar and the innovative allows him to showcase a deep appreciation for traditional French dishes while infusing them with a contemporary flair.
Passard’s decision to eliminate red meat from L’Arpège marked a pivotal moment for fine dining restaurants worldwide by prompting ventures into vegetarian and plant-based menus. Such is the case with the esteemed Eleven Madison Park in New York, ranked as the World’s Best Restaurant in 2017, which decided to go entirely vegan in 2021 (Guidara, 2022). Leading up to the twenty-first century, scepticism regarding the feasibility of such establishments was prevalent. Today, however, the culinary landscape is witnessing a celebration of the "green attitude", a term underscored by Wells (2007) and embraced by food critics, journalists, and discerning clients who applaud the sustainable and plant-centric approach pioneered by Passard. With growing awareness of climate change and economic and political challenges, sustainability has now become a focal point in the hospitality industry.
This shift is mirrored in the evaluations and accolades bestowed upon restaurants. It is no secret that awards play a crucial role in shaping a restaurant's reputation and ensuring its ongoing success (Edelheim et al., 2011). Amid the multitude of critics and organisations, the Michelin Guide stands out as one of the most authoritative global voices in evaluating culinary excellence (Chiang & Guo, 2021). Responding to the evolving landscape, Michelin (2021) introduced a new ranking criteria to their renowned guide in 2020, the Green Star, which exists alongside the traditional three Stars. This decoration specifically recognises and rewards establishments leading the way in sustainable practices. Those bestowed with a Green Star not only stand as ambassadors of sustainability but also serve as role models for others to emulate (Mrusek et al., 2021). The world witnessed a significant milestone with Restaurant ONA in south-west France becoming the first fully plant-based venue to receive a Green Star from Michelin in 2021, signifying a notable shift in a nation traditionally associated with meat-heavy dining preferences.
Additionally, Passard has contributed to the culinary space through the publication of his own cookbooks. Recognizing the pivotal role of cookbooks in shaping cooking trends and national culinary identities (Helstosky, 2003), Passard's 2015 culinary guide, The Art of Cooking With Vegetables, serves as a conduit for sharing his unique philosophy with a global audience. Within the preface of this work, he emphasises that the recipes feature “innovative, sometimes unimaginable, partnerships of ingredients to delight and surprise” (Passard, 2015, p.2). Furthermore, his prominent featuring in 2016 on Netflix's acclaimed series, Chef's Table, solidifies his status as a celebrity chef and a worldwide culinary figure, aligning him with esteemed predecessors such as Paul Bocuse, who served as an ambassador for the best of French gastronomy (Ferguson, 2010).
Despite his success, Passard’s departure from meat products has not escaped scrutiny. In France, Poulain (2002) underscores that preserving the patrimoine alimentaire familial, (‘family-linked’ food heritage) is considered by many as paramount, hence any departure from tradition could be damaging to the survival of long-standing techniques and dishes. Furthermore, as the culinary landscape increasingly emphasises sustainability, a new challenge has emerged in the form of "sustainability greenwashing." This phenomenon raises concerns about businesses leveraging sustainability as a marketing ploy rather than implementing genuine practices. Many sustainable efforts, often conducted behind the scenes, remain inconspicuous during dining (Charlebois et al., 2015), making it challenging for consumers to discern the actual value of these practices. The misuse of terms like "green" or "sustainable" tarnishes the reputation of legitimate businesses (Majeed & Kim, 2022), undermining the genuine efforts of establishments such as L’Arpège, and posing an ongoing issue that demands thoughtful consideration and resolution.
The culinary approach of Alain Passard reveals a captivating narrative of transformation and continuity. A visionary chef ahead of his time, he defied conventions and shaped the contemporary culinary landscape by embracing innovation while also staying connected to the rich traditions of French gastronomy. His decision to prioritise vegetables and establish his own farmland showcases an innovative approach to cooking and a commitment to sustainability, but ultimately a return to the roots of French culinary heritage by placing seasonal and local ingredients at the heart of cooking. Passard's creative spirit is further evidenced by his unconventional use of cooking techniques, applying his applauded meat preparation skills to the world of vegetables, revisiting classic dishes, and describing his food in a unique and novel manner. Importantly, Passard's influence has extended far beyond his restaurant, L'Arpège, as his commitment to sustainability and innovative culinary techniques has inspired a global shift toward plant-based and sustainable dining. The accolades and recognition from prestigious institutions like Michelin, in addition to public perception, highlight the legitimacy of his approach (Beaugé, 2008). As gastronomy continues to evolve, Alain Passard stands as a beacon of innovation, navigating the delicate balance between preserving the past and shaping the future of French cuisine.
References
Astier, I. (2015). Un parfum de paradis terrestre. Revue de la BNF, 49, 18–23.
https://doi.org/10.3917/rbnf.049.0018Beaugé, B. (2008). Comment dire qu’un talent est nouveau?. Les Annales de l’EPM, 14.
Bouty, I., & Gomez, M.-L. (2010). Des ressources à la pratique. Analyse de la stratégie légumière dans le champ de la haute cuisine. Revue française de gestion, 36, 149–161. https://doi.org/10.3166/rfg.203.149-161
Bouty, I., & Gomez, M.-L. (2011). The emergence of an influential practice: food for thought. Organization Studies, 32(7), 921–940. https://doi.org/10.1177/0170840611407020
Chiang, C. F., & Guo, H. W. (2021). Consumer perceptions of the Michelin Guide and attitudes toward Michelin-starred restaurants. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 93, 102793. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhm.2020.102793
Dupuy, J. P. (2009). Rhétorique du menu gastronomique. Communication & langages, 2, 19–33. https://doi.org/10.4074/S0336150009002026
Dupuy, J. (2012). Colors of caviar : le restaurant étoilé comme espace de représentation artistique. Sociétés & Représentations, 34, 99–111. https://doi.org/10.3917/sr.034.0099
Edelheim, J. R., Lee, Y. L., Lee, S. H., & Caldicott, J. (2011). Developing a taxonomy of ‘award-winning’ restaurants—What are they actually?. Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality & Tourism, 12(2), 140–156. https://doi.org/10.1080/1528008x.2011.541815
Ferguson, P. P. (2003). Writing out of the kitchen: Carême and the invention of French cuisine. Gastronomica: The Journal of Food and Culture, 3(3), 40–51. https://doi.org/10.1525/gfc.2003.3.3.40
Ferguson, P. P. (2010). Culinary nationalism. Gastronomica: The Journal of Food and Culture, 10(1), 102–109. https://doi.org/10.1525/gfc.2010.10.1.102
Geyzen, A., Leroy, F., & Scholliers, P. (2012). Innovative traditions in swiftly transforming foodscapes: An exploratory essay. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 24, 47–52. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tifs.2011.12.003
Guidara, W. (2022). Unreasonable hospitality. Tarcher.
Holtzman, J. D. (2006). Food and memory. Annual Review of Anthropology, 35, 361–378.
Helstosky, C. (2003). Recipe for the nation: Reading Italian history through La scienza in cucina and La cucina futurista. Food and Foodways: Explorations in the History and Culture of Human Nourishment, 11(2-3), 113–140. https://doi.org/10.1080/07409710390242372
Johnson, C., Surlemont, B., Nicod, P., & Revaz, F. (2005). Behind the stars: A concise typology of Michelin restaurants in Europe. Cornell Hospitality Quarterly, 46(2), 170–187.
Kallmuenzer, A., Kraus, S., & Montargot, N. (2022). Haute cuisine three-star restaurants’ representation on websites and dining guides: a lexicometric analysis. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 34(9), 3376–3393. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJCHM-07-2021-0851
Magid, A. M. (2004). You are what you eat: literary probes into the palate. Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Michelin. (2021). Le guide Michelin.
Mrusek, N., Ottenbacher, M. C., & Harrington, R. J. (2021). The impact of sustainability and leadership on the innovation management of Michelin-Starred chefs. Sustainability, 14(1), 330. https://doi.org/10.3390/su14010330
Passard, A. (2013). Jazz en cuisine. Le journal de l’école de Paris du management, 99, 17–21. https://doi.org/10.3917/jepam.099.0017
Passard, A. (2015). The art of cooking with vegetables. Frances Lincoln.
Poulain, J.-P. (2002). Sociologies de l'alimentation: les mangeurs et l'espace social alimentaire.
Presses Universitaires de France. https://doi.org/10.3917/puf.poul.2013.01
Schehr, L. R., & Weiss, A. S. (2001). French food: on the table, on the page, and in French culture. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203952795
Urry, J. (1990). The tourist gaze: Leisure and travel in contemporary society. Sage.
Wells, P. (2007). Vegetable harvest: Vegetables at the centre of the plate. William Morrow.
Wilson, J. E. (1998). Terroir: The role of geology, climate, and culture in the making of French wines. University of California Press.